You are here
Home > Region > Hong Kong > Should You Start Your Investment Banking Career in Hong Kong?

Should You Start Your Investment Banking Career in Hong Kong?

Traditionally, the best places to start an investment banking career have been New York and London. Some people consider San Francisco on par – especially for TMT and healthcare.

However, with Asia (driven by China) becoming the engine of the world’s growth, a lot of people are wondering if Hong Kong is the place to start when receiving multiple offers across various jurisdictions. We have been in Asia for a few years now and it is true it is where the action is.

Investment Banking All-In Salaries in Hong Kong

Adding to this is the extremely low taxes in Hong Kong. The Financial Times recently put together a feature where it showed that over the career of a banker in Hong Kong, he could expect to make twice as much as a banker in New York and four times as much as a banker in London (expect a banker in Canada to make about the same as a banker in London).

This is because Hong Kong salaries are the same as in New York (which are higher than London) while the tax caps out around 15% (expect to pay up to 50% or more in New York).

In addition to this, tax is applied at the end of the tax year in Hong Kong and there is no tax on capital gains or dividends. In terms of compounding wealth, assuming the same lifestyle, expect a Hong Kong banker to have 8 times the net worth of a London banker at the end of a career.

So especially now, as U.S. visas for investment banking jobs are being rejected and candidates having the option to start their careers in other global offices, this question becomes even more relevant.

The answer is no – you should not start your investment banking career in Hong Kong.

China growing very fast is an excellent investing opportunity but not an excellent investment banking opportunity. The Chinese economy has expanded but capital markets, although massive, have not kept pace. There is a lot of money tied up in private equity, a lot of companies that fund liquidity with mostly cash instead of bonds and very lax regulatory systems.

This is because the average Chinese, although major savers, do not have direct exposure to the markets. So while important, investor protections in a retail dominated market are not at the top of the list of the Chinese Communist Party’s agenda.

Investment Banking Work in Hong Kong

What does this mean for a junior investment banker? It means that while regulatory frameworks relating to takeover rules, allowed share repurchases, significant shareholders and listing rules will become drilled into your head – a solid understanding of valuation and corporate finance strategies will not.

Also, while the aspects mentioned above are from an execution perspective, many senior Chinese bankers actually have a weak understanding of the execution work because they rely heavily on relationships. These things together mean that the learning is limited to more qualitative work.

A lot of the market trading comps or credit analysis is meaningless because the most important thing is to move volume. So instead of building models there is a lot more time put into doing logo splashes and creds pages (not to discount the monotony of logo splashes and qualifications pages in New York) and rehashing boilerplate prospectuses rather than doing any real analysis or contributing to real advice.

When I moved over to work in a fund I was flabbergasted with the average understanding of corporate finance for investment bankers at major bulge brackets. They literally knew nothing compared to where I came from. Chinese credit is even more of a wild west.

This is not necessarily because the bankers are dumber – but there is no substitute for doing real investment banking work in being a good investment banker. Being surrounded by colleagues with a weaker understanding of finance is also detrimental to growth. Note this is more pronounced at local brokerages that do not have to interact with global coworkers and undergo a standardized orientation and training program.

Relationship Hires in Hong Kong and China

Knowing that the real hard work in valuation and modeling is not all that important, Chinese firms will focus on the only aspect that truly matters – the relationship aspect. So when they hire, they will have a bias to clients’ kids.

Senior bankers may also be afraid to step on toes of some juniors, making for an awkward work environment.

The JP Morgan sons and daughters type hiring is too pronounced. Now don’t get me wrong, in many offices in New York across the biggest names in finance there are plenty of analysts that are hired on Daddy versus merit – maybe as many as 50% in some offices. From the people I have met at Bulge Brackets, the number is 75% in Hong Kong and for domestic brokerages I am sure it is 100%.

This is again not conducive to a good learning experience. Funnily enough, this is not limited to banking but also to accountancy and BigLaw (you would think law would be spared). Even major management consultancies have plenty of what I would consider fake intern roles for the privileged. Then again I met a doctor in Toronto who got in through her father – careful when you are getting a surgery.

Everyone is someone’s kid in Hong Kong. I am currently having a few drinks with an idiot whose family controls a $2 billion USD listed company. I trust he will never read this website.

Last of all, the hours are just as bad if not worse. On one hand, there is less hard analysis so it is less mentally taxing. On the other hand, it means that VPs and MDs have ridiculous requests that have you staying in the office until 3 in the morning on a regular basis. This is a horrible use of your 20’s.

Also, society generally views the workplace in a way that human resources in North America or Europe would find ghastly. On one hand, I rolled my eyes at political correctness in Corporate America. On the other hand, some of the stuff I see here is mind boggling. I will leave it at that.

Investment Banking Offer Hong Kong versus New York

Of course, this only really applies when you have comparable competing offers in New York or London.

You should readily select Morgan Stanley Hong Kong over a no-name investment bank or possibly even a mid-market bank because of the brand value. It becomes a harder decision when you have an option to work for a Chinese broker such as China Renaissance or China Merchants in Hong Kong versus Deloitte Corporate Finance in New York.

Also, the high compensation is only really valid with global firms – elite boutiques and bulge brackets pay street. If you start your career in BOCOM Real Estate investment banking you may be subject to Hong Kong compensation practices – we may write a post on this later.

If you have no offer at all elsewhere, take it! Don’t forget to thank your dad.

Of course after you get promoted to associate or VP, for sure make the jump. Take advantage of the gravy train while you can.

Avatar
Matt
ex investment banking associate
https://www.linkedin.com/in/matt-walker-ssh/

Leave a Reply

Top