A Collection of Stories about Bubbles, Bitcoin and Cryptocurrencies Trends by Matt - January 11, 2018July 10, 20180 Word on the street is that this morning, an analyst on the trading floor walked into his managing director’s office and said that he was out. When asked why, he mentioned that he got into Bitcoin at $4. We do not know any details beyond that, but must have been an awkward encounter with some sheepish smiles and an MD wondering how the analyst has so much more money than him. We were not planning on putting together an article on Bitcoin and the other cryptocurrencies because we do not know that much about the space – however, as the stories are coming in fast and thick we may as well share some anecdotes before the crypto trade collapses or replaces the current monetary system thus proving Bitcoin evangelists right. Our Personal Experience with Bitcoin Over a hundred people have personally asked us about cryptocurrencies over the last few years. In 2011, a friend from junior high told us that he was using Bitcoin to purchase herbs via the Silk Road (marijuana, another bubble). He said he had $40 worth of Bitcoin and gave a spiel about replacing the monetary system which we saw as a conspiracy theory. We told him to sell his Bitcoin and he did. In 2014, one of our friends in lending told us that they were interested in Bitcoin because of a post on Reddit that piqued their interest. They were ready to put down $5,000 as play money. We told them that it sounded like a conspiracy theory and to invest in TD instead. In fairness, this has not turned out to be a bad investment on an absolute scale – at least we did not recommend Valeant. Last year, a structurer asked us about Bitcoin – we would think that the structurer should known more about cryptocurrencies than we do, so given that he was ignorant about the asset class/currency, he had no business being in Bitcoin. He listened and bought a pharmaceutical instead which he also had no business being in and lost all his money. Anyways, we plausibly may have deprived our lower income friends from a better life for themselves and their families. As such, it is understandable that we are reluctant to offer any sort of investment advice pertaining to any asset class. Good thing we are rich though. What We Find Interesting About Cryptocurrencies Conversely, a few friends working in corporate roles have told us that they have made hundreds of thousands in the last few months starting with $5,000-$10,000 via Ripple, Ethereum and Litecoin. They are laughing, as they have made investment banking bonuses without suffering in investment banking – all the while paying capital gains tax instead of the income tax slapped onto bonuses. However, the people who are really laughing are cryptocurrency “founders” – some more unscrupulous ones who know nothing about digital currency but ran ICOs to steal money, and ones who are experts in the space and have become billionaires. A few days ago, the man who founded Ripple became the 5th richest person in the world. He is not anymore, but still quite the accomplishment. Likewise, we were amused when the founder of Litecoin sold all of his Litecoin to get rid of any “conflicts of interest”. He is probably right, but it is just funny when people are really rich. China and Bitcoin China has had an interesting relationship with bitcoin so far, with many citizens purchasing bitcoin as a way to store money – but definitely also as a speculation vehicle, as the Chinese market is one of the most prone to mania as evidenced by the 2015 stock run up and housing anywhere around the world. Bitcoin has also been used as a conduit to move money out – not necessarily for money laundering, but for bypassing capital controls set out to curb outflows and protect the strength of the RMB. However, China has also been a leading bitcoin miner. Mining bitcoin has a business model that is not dissimilar to traditional mining. All the easy bitcoin is mined first, while future bitcoin to be mined requires a large amount of processing power to solve equations. As the cost of mining bitcoin (in terms of electricity) rises, the cost curve changes. Some of the cheapest electricity is found in the poorer western provinces, and accordingly, the cost of mining a bitcoin is far lower in certain areas of China versus most other places on earth. With a central government run by technocrats, vast bitcoin mining operations have run afoul of the authorities who see profiteers mining for speculation without any tangible benefit to society. As such, mining is being curbed – but not without a policy headache, as these jobs will have to be replaced to keep social discontent low. The cost curve accordingly moves left as these Chinese miners are taken offline. However, pragmatic companies, including quite a few Chinese firms are looking for new jurisdictions that have cheap electricity to set up Bitcoin farms. Recently they have been looking at hydro powered Quebec while the Pacific Northwest (Washington and Oregon) are also looking at attracting any business to stimulate their regional economies. Previous Bubbles Before Bitcoin We have seen a lot of bubbles come and go over the last few years – and they all seem to follow the same pattern. After the financial crisis, China carried the world out of economic malaise via heavy government spending with a focus on natural resources and industry. The mining sector saw incredible gains and junior miners, of which a significant number are some of the worst companies an amateur can invest in, saw huge run ups in share price, going from penny stocks to a few dollars. Half of these miners did not have any sort of development plan, never mind production – they just had rights to land that was extremely speculative at best and drilled a hole. Analysts called it a supercycle and spun the story that stocks would just keep going up. China could not afford to slow things down and quantitative easing meant that gold was going to $5,000 an ounce. One of our classmates got a job at a “boutique investment bank” – which was a boiler room in Vancouver’s hipster-yuppie Yaletown neighbourhood. He would call seniors in Florida and Arizona and peddle stocks representing random lots of land in Mexico and Argentina that had about as much gold as the beach. These securities were over-the-counter pink sheets – completely illiquid and once an investor took the plunge they were never getting their money back. Commissions were 25% to 50% of what they sold. Needless to say, once major miners such as Teck and Barrick started to suffer due to market oversupply, this market collapsed. Any time Vancouver is a leader in capital markets, there is assuredly something amiss in the markets. Vancouver also reminds us of Ballard Power – another Vancouver darling, and Plug Power – which ran up some insane amount before a scathing research report came out and brought the stock down to earth. Shortly after I graduated, a Japanese friend was sending around a Youtube video on 3D printing. The video demonstrated how colorful blocks were put into a contraption we now know to be a 3D printer and out came detailed anime figurines. The narrative was that these printers could replace factories and workers to build anything, from AK-47s to computers. The addressable market was huge. 3D Systems, Stratasys and Voxeljet skyrocketed before running into the same problems as the other bubbles and not getting anywhere close to the market that analysts set out for them. Accordingly, we personally do not give too much credit to the comparison between the market capitalization of all cryptocurrencies and gold, which to some bitcoin proponents is the best comparable. As a best case scenario, it seems to work, but it will take much more market acceptance to get there. Two years after the big mining collapse, oil was at $120 per barrel and ISIS was advancing on Baghdad. The market ignored all of the supply coming on from US shale and misread OPEC’s strategy, leading to a spectacular decline in oil prices that has only recovered today. Bitcoin is Different From the Other Bubbles Although the run-up has been an extremely accentuated version of some of the previous examples, we would like to note that 1) we have been wrong in the past; and 2) the supporters of bitcoin are far more sophisticated than any of the aforementioned bubbles outlined above. While some of the smartest investors that we pay attention to, including Warren Buffett, have come out and denounced the cryptomania, we have also found many people much smarter than us who have developed compelling theses on why it is a revolutionary product. We will not elaborate further here, but there is an abundance of literature to be found on Quora and other platforms for interested readers. That said, Bitcoin’s “exclusivity” has now also been diminished because every major cryptocurrency runs a similar model – although they are trying to differentiate. As an investor, which crypto is the right one? Should you hold a basket? Without research, it is hard to have comfort unless you are playing on momentum. The bigger idea is blockchain and ledgers, and it is hard to say that these will not find applications in fiat currency, possibly making the cryptocurrency craze less revolutionary. Is Getting into Bitcoin Now an Awful Idea? In the news, there are a few examples of people going into credit card debt or even remortgaging their houses to get into bitcoin and contemporaries. This is a bad idea – we are willing to go out on a limb and say this. However, if investors know what they stand to lose and are comfortable with it, it could work out. A lot of people who are invested also think that Bitcoin is a bubble – but in such a frothy market, a rising tide lifts all boats, and Bitcoin is by far the most volatile one. Also, it is fun and a good story. We, ourselves, do not believe in speculation – which is why we are poor. Nonetheless, we do not recommend anything that we ourselves do not do. Related Reading for Investing InvestingWhat I Missed About Tesla Stock · Are Stocks Cheap After COVID-19 – Part II · Real Estate Investment Considerations and Strategies · Why Investment Bankers Are Bad Investors · The Sky Is Falling · Beginning Investor Q&A · Choosing the Right Investment Advisor · Understanding China and the Investment Thesis · Emerging Markets We Are Investing In Right Now (for Canadians) · Investing in Stocks Today with the Trump Backdrop · Buying Property as an Investment for Young Professionals · Observations on Chinese Assets and Investing · Should You Enroll in the Company Employee Share/Stock Purchase Plan (ESPP)? · Dividend Reinvestment Plans (DRIP) · Investing Mistakes for Family and Friends · A Conversation About Risk and Reward · Share on Facebook Share Share on TwitterTweet Share on LinkedIn Share Print Print