You are here
Home > Mutual Funds > What Are Segregated Funds? Should You Buy Segregated Funds?

What Are Segregated Funds? Should You Buy Segregated Funds?

Segregated funds are mutual funds with embedded derivatives or insurance policies. For instance, a segregated fund may be a mutual fund that is similar to most other mutual funds except that they will guarantee 75% of your initial investment provided that you do not collect your money for 10 years. Sounds like a good deal right?

Wrong! Here are some of the problems with that.

  • Mutual funds as a standalone are expensive enough as is, with punitive management expense ratios (MER) up to 3%. This means that every year, up to 3% of your investment, win or lose, is docked off to pay the mutual fund company. With the additional insurance on the loan, you are paying an excess on top of the already high MER – since the new fee is blended, it is hard to discern what is insurance and what is MER and segregated funds will price to take advantage of the lack of transparency
  • The probability of your investment falling below 75% over a 10-year period is very difficult given that they are spread out in a basket of stocks – if you competitively priced this insurance, it would be practically worthless
  • For funds that guarantee all of your initial capital, this will be made whole to the fund through a higher MER or some other mechanism
  • Usually these stocks will be similar to a market index (index huggers) because fund companies that peddle these products are more interested in not making the wrong decision than to generate value for investors – since you are going to get a return that is a little bit worse than the index, you may as well buy the index and save 3% tax. This 3% may not seem like much but compounded over time, it makes a significant toll on your wealth. To put into perspective, the market goes up 7-8% on average every year, so half of your money will go to the fund instead of to you
  • If you pull out early, your return bottom is not guaranteed and you may face a financial penalty on top of your losses

On top of all of that, sometimes these funds will still come with commissions:

  • A front-end load for ~5% of the investment, meaning you start off with $95 out of the $100 you invested right away, losing a full year of investment returns right off the bat
  • A deferred sales charge (DSC) up to 7%, where you are locked in while the DSC is amortized or forgiven over 5 years – if you pull out earlier, you will be responsible for the unforgiven portion of the DSC – which is exorbitant
  • A “low-load”, which is marketed as a cheap commission product, ignoring the fact that most premier funds do not come with any loads

Our view is the same for practically every other structured product for retail investors. The vast majority is heavily priced and at best you will not be worse off just picking a safe basket of conservative stocks or a balanced fund with short term bonds.

You should never buy segregated funds. Because the funds are structured and therefore complex to the average investor, the pricing behind the insurance and the stocks/bonds is extremely in favor of the segregated fund company. Insurers, who are natural purveyors of segregated funds given the insurance component, make some of their highest revenues from these products.

There is a reason why financial companies can afford to pay such high commissions to their independent contractor salesmen – these products are extremely lucrative. Mutual funds sold by banks never have loads anymore and many investors are shifting to passive investing via ETFs that replicate major market indices such as the S&P 500 and S&P/TSX – stick with those instead.

Mutual FundsQuestions to Ask When Picking A Mutual Fund · Choosing the Right Investment Advisor · What Are Segregated Funds? Should You Buy Segregated Funds? · Benchmarking & Performance Evaluation for Mutual Funds ·
Avatar
Matt
ex investment banking associate
https://www.linkedin.com/in/matt-walker-ssh/

Leave a Reply

Top