You are here
Home > Real Estate Investing > The Best Initial Investment is Not a Stock

The Best Initial Investment is Not a Stock

Select City Residential Real Estate Has Been The Best Asset Class

When I was a wee boy growing up on the North Shore of British Columbia, my parents had told me that only fools rent and the best way to build wealth early is to hold real estate. After all, that was how they became fabulously wealthy and how we ended up on the North Shore.1 That is also probably why I went to Western and became an investment banker, but I digress.

Globally, anyone acquainted with the news is aware of Vancouver housing prices beating just about anything that is not AMZN, NVDA and for some short period of time, Bitcoin. So they were right, although I will caution that listening to blanket statements like buy real estate are meaningless – we will expand on that here.

When I started in investment banking, a number of my vintage ended up purchasing condos – or putting down 20-25% equity – while the rest of them figured that prices had gone up rather much relative to income and figured that the growth would not be sustainable. They were also semi-lying – they just spent far too much of their money on King West.

However, about 80% of my accountant friends – the nerdy types that are never going to make partner – quietly picked up property. The down payment was measurably more difficult than for my investment banking cohort, but they found ways to stretch in order to make the payment – whether from the bank of mom and dad or their savings from working in the library during university.

Once their salaries started to exceed mortgage payments (and they usually rented out the apartment while they continued to live with mom and dad – something that investment bankers cannot due to the proximity of the office to suburbia), they would take the plunge on a second apartment the moment they amassed enough.

I can assure you that the aggregate net worth of these accountants, many of whom are now senior managers at Deloitte/KPMG, is far higher than that of the investment bankers that graduated in the same year, despite starting at a quarter of the all-in compensation and now a fifth.

Real Estate Works… Because of Leverage

Apartments in downtown Toronto have doubled or tripled – as any LBO lover could tell you, putting in 20-25% equity into the purchase price means that your return is xxx over xxx amount of years.

Let’s say someone does a great job at picking stocks and purchases Brookfield Asset Management one year when it goes up 15% and pays a ~4% dividend for a total return of 19%. He has beaten the stock market and 90% of investors – pat on the back.

Someone picks a random studio in Yaletown for $100,000 down on a $400,000 condo. It goes up 10% to $440,000. He rents it out for $2,000 a month and after condo fees and property tax he gets another $14,400 per year. He made a 54% return and he didn’t have to kill himself to pick the right stock.

And that’s not even realistic – this is what actually happens:

Someone picks a random condo in Cityplace, Toronto for $100,000 down on a $400,000 condo. It goes up to $600,000 the next year for a $200,000 gain on $100,000 initial capital. A 200% return. Forget the rental.

You can’t do this with a stock. For one, you have a far greater chance of getting wiped out if you are wrong but it is doubtful a house in Calgary is going to zero even if the oil price crashes. And banks will not let you lever up this much – you are at risk of getting margin called.

People have made multiples on their capital. The rent pays the interest and some of the principal.

This is an interesting lookback, but as our profession caveats daily – past performance is not indicative of future results. So is this dynamic still valid?

And the answer is that it totally is – real estate will continue to be your best investment as a young professional unless you can spot the next Amazon. That said, we have to explore some of the drivers for this price appreciation before blindly throwing money into real estate.

Not all real estate is created equal.

Why Is Vancouver Different? Why is Toronto Different?

The phrase people associate most closely with real estate is Location, Location, Location.

This holds true as it always will. Canadian real estate has risen relative to incomes, but pockets of it will continue to go up while others will become stagnant. Prices are about supply and demand and real estate, as illiquid as it is compared to stocks or bonds, is no exception. We know that there will be divergence from true value and true demand when markets become irrational and asset bubbles form due to speculative behavior.

We have seen that in Canada where because national prices skyrocketed, people did not look at the underlying drivers and had FOMO – making prices across the country in Pickering, Barrie and Prince George go up. These are illogical price actions and undesirable suburbia has already started to retreat. However, as a city dweller – especially one that works in a growing city with large scale immigration and a strong economy to boot, you will do just fine. The pace of price increases will slow – you will not get 300% returns like my graduating class, but you are getting more of a sure bet than picking stocks, which you probably suck at.

What is the main reason behind that? It is primarily Chinese purchasing habits – as xenophobic letters to newspapers and racist comments on Youtube videos on the topic would suggest.

This is not a bad thing and we disavow any sort of commentary that suggests that it is. There are failures with public policy that could be solved by relaxing density restrictions – population density contributes to our favorite topic – economies of scale and more people and tangible mass transit solutions equals vibrant cities.

However, our site is not out to convince anyone about anything on a moral level, we are just telling you that this will continue to be a good investment because Chinese immigration trends and purchasing biases will continue in core areas.

Outbound Chinese Real Estate Investment

The first phenomenon is predominantly Chinese, but not inherently Chinese. We live in a globalized world that is getting smaller and smaller and international wealth, Chinese or otherwise, continues to be attracted to livable cities with excellent service industries, strong legal frameworks and structured education systems.

When people buy globally it is partially to park wealth, but a major consideration is their children.

The anglosphere West has persistently provided for a repeatable and beatable trajectory towards a stable, white-collar life with no shortage of comforts pertaining to dining and entertainment.

If you study hard, you will matriculate and go to a good university and subsequently be positioned for a good job – sometimes an investment banker. The competition is far easier than in your home country where it is cutthroat – and this because there are structural barriers to education and social mobility. Once school is finished and immigrants settle and become accustomed to the pace of life, they remain.

In this regard, Vancouver, Melbourne, Sydney, Auckland, Toronto and London will always be top destinations. As the world gets smaller, these aforementioned cities become more attractive.

Pockets of the US used to fall under this category – most notably the San Gabriel Valley in California and Rochester and Queens in New York – but it is less obvious that it is as welcoming as it was in the past. China’s rise has antagonized the global order and trade war developments with the current Presidential administration may start a secular shift away from Chinese seeing the US as the land of opportunity. Chinese will be discouraged from travel, work and education in America by both their own and the US government. While policy may change if Trump is pushed out before the next election, the allure of the USA is already fading fast – the damage is irrepairable. The fact that the US becomes a less attractive location should boost the attractiveness of Canadian and Australian go-tos even more.

The fact that Chinese citizens are acting on this trend is solely due to the fact that much of growth in wealth over the last twenty has been, and for the next twenty years, will be, Chinese.

The other aspect is more inherently Chinese – Chinese communities tend to gravitate towards ethnic enclaves. Now this is not unique to Chinese immigrants because there are Koreatowns, Little Indias and Little Havanas everywhere – however the pure scale of Chinese immigration lessens the pressure of assimilation, while the large bamboo network and global business environment fosters Chinese focused areas for when business is conducted outside of China.

The multiples of income for housing prices is irrelevant when compared to other North American cities because the multiples for Denver or Houston serve local or national markets while Vancouver and Melbourne serve global markets. If Houston is an option for 15 million people, Vancouver is an option for 300 million people.

Will these trends continue? We certainly think so – Chinese GDP growth will continue to lead the world while population flattens or even declines (per capita wealth increases). The more concentrated immigration becomes, the more attractive these cities are (especially specific neighbourhoods or suburbs).

Can policy arrest housing price rises? Not for lack of effort, but politicians have rolled in value-added taxes for non-citizens and vacancy penalties for empty homes. However, with naturally declining and aging populations, Canada and Australia need immigration – and affluent and educated immigrants are the ideal candidates. These immigrants will accordingly disproportionately include Chinese nationals.

One aspect that no one has noticed, but may well change in the next five to ten years is political activism. Asians have historically not been targeted as a voter group because they are not politically involved. They are not politically involved because they are not acquainted with democracy – just legal frameworks. Eventually they will wake up as a monolithic group and push for shared interests – the ramifications of this shift we cannot opine on as it is at best conjecture. This can mean even more tailwinds for housing prices in the right areas.

What is the Next Vancouver for Real Estate?

We have rambled on about these trends and why prices will go up in specific areas. But what is the specific area of tomorrow if we had to wager?

Well fortunately, we have already wagered – it is Markham/Richmond Hill/Scarborough – namely Downtown Markham. We feel it is the opportunity of today because it is still in the nascent stages of development.

Do we want to live there? Almost definitely not, but this is a profitable and repeatable case study that has played out multiple times in the past – and not just in Canada.

Richmond, Metrotown Burnaby, Westwood Plateau Coquitlam, Arcadia/San Gabriel Valley, Melbourne, Sydney, Auckland – the same thing happens and the property prices jump exponentially.

Downtown Markham is what #3 Road in Richmond, British Columbia looked like 20 years ago. Richmond has a lot of land that does not appreciate, but this one corridor that has a strong commercial/residential mixed use presence has skyrocketed in value. Today, it is full up with apartments, food choices, business parks and mass transit options.

What you will notice is that the feel – architecture and materials – of restaurants and malls is similar to Tier 1 and 2 Chinese cities – which is exactly what they are trying to replicate. There are already Ferrarris in the parking lots and high tea outlets being set up.

So maybe have a lot of night outs at Citizen – celebrate! You’re an investment. Banker.

Or maybe use your signing bonus and sell your mother a $75,000 promissory note at a below market rate and buy an apartment. Thank us in a few years, donations welcome.

tl;dr:

Houses in dead suburbs will fall – like Detroit – just watch them rot
Apartments in globally attractive areas up

1. Poverty begets poverty and social mobility is a lie

2. Investment bankers were making ~$130,000 as analysts while PwC was ~$35,000

Real EstateImpact of COVID-19 on Real Estate Investments · Modeling Commercial Real Estate · Buying Real Estate as an Investment · Sale and Leaseback Transactions in Investment Banking · Investment Banking for Dummies · Buying Property as an Investment for Young Professionals · Interview with: Real Estate Commercial Banking VP · Trends in Real Estate in Canada · No Bubble in Vancouver and Trends in Real Estate in Canada · How to Analyze REITS – Case Study: RioCan · Real Estate ·
Avatar
Matt
ex investment banking associate
https://www.linkedin.com/in/matt-walker-ssh/

Leave a Reply

Top