Spreading Investment Banking Comps: Preferred, Minority Interest and Adjusting for Subsequent Events Trading Comparables by Matt - March 17, 2019March 17, 20190 In previous posts, we addressed the equity and debt components in the enterprise value formula: EV = Equity + Debt – Cash & Marketable Securities + Preferred Shares + Minority Interest + Asset Retirement Obligations + Capitalized Operating Leases + Pension Obligations – Investments (including investments in affiliates, long-term investments) + Present Value of Hedges and Risk Management – Net Working Capital This post will address the remaining items. Preferred Equity in Enterprise Value Along with debt and equity, preferred equity makes up another important part of the capital stack. Similar to debt, when calculating enterprise value, investment analysts will use the face value of the preferred shares rather than the market value of the preferred shares unless they are in financial distress. This is for simplicity – theoretically, if the preferreds are trading well below par value (usually owing to interest rates rising if the company is otherwise healthy), the corporate can tender for them or repurchase them on the open market at the discounted value. Similar to convertible debt, preferred shares with convertible options that are in the money should technically trade at their equity value with dilutive effects. For distributable cash flow (DCF – not to be confused with discounted cash flow), which is funds from operation less maintenance capex less preferred dividends, the dividend on the preferred shares will affect this metrics and the multiples that it feeds into. Accounting for Minority Interest and Investments in Enterprise Value There are cases where a separate entity owns part of a subsidiary of the company. So for example, if Google’s Waymo (autonomous driving subsidiary) was 20% owned by Volkswagen or Daimler AG (at current this is not the case but topical because Alphabet Inc has been reported to be open to third party investment in Waymo), Google would fully consolidate Waymo entirely but break out the minority interest line under equity. Usually, minority interest is in a private subsidiary (that is not traded on an exchange), so the book value is the best observable value. The equity market value of Alphabet Inc. will already reflect that a certain amount of Waymo is not owned by the parent. Good examples of this can include relationship investments by financial sponsors. However, sometimes corporations will have subsidiaries that are also publicly traded. This is popular with companies with yieldco arms – be it in power generation, infrastructure, pipelines or real estate. The shares that are not owned by the parent are minority interest. However, they do have an observable market value as the subsidiary trades publicly. The shares that are not owned should be marked-to-market based on current share price. The opposite dynamic is when the corporate owns investments – especially equity affiliates where they own a minority stake and do not control the entity. If there is an observable market value this should be used. While minority interest is added to EV, investments are subtracted from EV similar to cash. Accounting for Cash-like Instruments in Enterprise Value While investments are treated like cash – a reduction to EV, there are other balance sheet elements that are also theoretically treated like cash but rarely in practice. Marketable securities are basically treated as cash. However, there are other accounts that are additive to equity value and deducted from enterprise value such as restricted cash, net working capital, and mark-to-market gains on hedges. Restricted cash cannot be readily used but the asset is still there in terms of an acquisition. Net working capital would mean receivables and inventory less payables and other current liabilities. Usually, this will exclude the current portion of ARO, debt and capitalized leases (otherwise they are being double counted). These are all assets that belong to the firm that have a positive influence on equity value. To be extremely theoretical and academic, if the inventory is comprised of raw materials, that can be marked to the current commodity price too. Obviously, this level of precision is asinine and should be ignored. The current hedge book can also be deducted from enterprise value (however if the hedge book is at a loss, this is added to enterprise value as it is a claim on the firm before equity). Factoring in Subsequent Event Checks and Scanning Press Releases When material events occur, companies have to report the corresponding changes to their shareholders. This is usually documented via a press release or 8-K filing. This could be an equity raise, debt raise, merger or other event. Investment analysts will accordingly add shares and cash for any equity raises, debt and cash for debt raises, and make adjustments for any merger or consolidation. So if American Express purchases a small payment technology firm for $2 billion using all cash after the financials are released, cash should be reduced by $2 billion. EBITDA estimates should go up and be reflected in broker estimates while what the market views the change is to the enterprise value should be reflected in movements in the stock price. If there was an equity raise, the cash added would be the # of shares sold at the clearing price less underwriter discounts while the share count would increase by the number of shares disclosed. There is also a subsequent events section in the financials which will break out relevant changes that need to be accounted for after the reporting period. Trading ComparablesPrecedent Transaction Comparables · Market Trading Comps for Investment Banking · Spreading Investment Banking Comps: Preferred, Minority Interest and Adjusting for Subsequent Events · Spreading Investment Banking Comps: Net Debt · Spreading Investment Banking Comps: Calculating Fully Diluted Market Capitalization · Spreading Trading Comps for Investment Banking · Share on Facebook Share Share on TwitterTweet Share on LinkedIn Share Print Print