You are here
Home > Coronavirus > Geopolitics After COVID-19 and Market Reaction

Geopolitics After COVID-19 and Market Reaction

When Does the COVID Recovery Start

The world will not be the same after the coronavirus and will adjust to a new normal. Now when the dust settles is another question. Is reopening up now a good idea when new cases are still springing up and people are dying at a rate of 3,000 a day?

Not sure – and we would imagine that any second or third waves of the coronavirus before a vaccine is developed will delay a recovery until well into 2021 or beyond. The supply chain is too connected, and the longer the recession/depression is, the more dominos will fall.

Right now the markets are down 25% – with all of the money being printed the real figure is more like 30 or 35% – so there is no indication there is a lot of appetite for risk-on behavior.

For example, if a retailer goes bankrupt, the banks take a hit and have to hold the keys and liquidate while their suppliers (manufacturers) and logistics firms do not get paid. They in turn have difficulties with their debt service and things start to spiral out of control. The flow of money is choked off and there are less consumption dollars, leading to a continued erosion of consumer discretionary spending. At some point, banks will become stressed and fail – although they are in a much stronger financial position versus 2008.

The solution we seem to be leaning towards is massive quantitative easing, destroying savings, bond values and the middle class (recall that deflation is good for bond investors and inflation is bad because you receive a nominal/inflation unadjusted principal at maturity).

And when the dust settles, we are already gearing for geopolitical conflict because it is one of the only truly bipartisan safe spaces in pointing the finger at China. Somebody is going to pay a price.

So, what could happen?

Hot War with China after COVID-19

Instead of a cold war, an outcome could be guns being fired. No nuclear war will be contemplated because everyone dies, as well as being a moral issue. There is a non-zero chance of this happening, as there is some grassroots support in the US and it provides a great distraction while a historically hawkish executive branch is in place.

A hot war would be fought around the South China Sea and could feasibly start with a blockade or a charade around Taiwan/red line of Chinese sovereignty where a freedom/oppression story could be sold to the general populace.

The idea is that if China can be defeated decisively on the open seas, they will be choked off and forced to cede to Western demands. The ideal outcomes from a US foreign policy perspective are one of: 1) China’s rise is set back for 50 years; 2) Regime change and the end of CCP rule with the replacement government aligned with US interests; 3) A fracturing of the country into regional factions.

The cost to both the US and China would be immense, with the greatest geopolitical beneficiary being Russia.

This is probably unlikely in the end because the cost-benefit is skewed heavily to the cost side.

For Americans, support for this war if it happens (if there was support to begin with) will wane because the human cost is too high – especially after citizens have had time to reflect on Iraq and Afghanistan. The war will likely be fought on a bilateral basis as most nations would not be willing to make this sacrifice.

Likewise, there are too many vested interests in China for influential US forces – especially corporates and Donald Trump himself. To attack China directly will destroy earnings and growth targets because multinationals are deprived of their largest growth engine. Expect everyone from Starbucks to Lululemon to boycott any escalation with vigor.

For the Chinese, this is an existential question which will be fueled by a never again mindset after a century of humiliation. For the Chinese, any major concession would cause them to lose face as they feel that they have been bullied into unfair treaties since the Qing Dynasty. The appetite for loss is much larger – so any war would be drawn out with major artillery employed.

The difference between China and Iraq is that there is a much more technologically advanced military and a state with much deeper pockets.

If this happens, everything is going to sell off and you will likely be unemployed. There is no real hedge here, even if you massively store physical gold someone will probably shoot and loot you.

Chinese Sanctions in Response to COVID-19

US sanctions can be crippling, as evidenced by the situation in Iran right now.

For this to work effectively, there needs to be appropriate buy-in from global partners. This will likely be flatly rejected by traditional US allies on any meaningful scale because China is too important to their own export economies. If the US wanted to lock out China from using the US financial system, US MNCs would lobby heavily against this for obvious reasons.

The harm to the Chinese economy, although great, would be mitigated by the massive and diversified domestic economy with 1.4 billion people that are switching from investment and saving to consumption.

The risk of retaliation is also too great. There are too many items in the US supply chain that depend heavily on China, especially as it pertains to healthcare solutions. This would be a non-starter.

If anything, this would lead to an acceleration of the decline in the US dollar as a vehicle currency because actions are perceived to be too arbitrary and volatile when such a currency needs to offer stability. China would also start pushing the yuan as an alternative.

US Sanctions on individuals is a more likely outcome, similar to what has been done with Russia.

If the sanctions are soft and not absolute, expect the global economy to recover and stocks continue to be biased to the upside.

Bifurcation of the Global Economy post COVID

This will happen to some extent anyway, the question is how deep the divide becomes. This is also not mutually exclusive versus the aforementioned two scenarios.

A key theme of COVID is that many sovereigns have felt overexposed to China, as evidenced by their desperation for PPE and other key goods. Moving of supply chains will likely happen, if not domestically, then to other nations such as Vietnam and the Philippines. In theory, the world can move towards two camps, one led by China and one led by the US as mistrust increases.

There are players that will switch sides in between as foreign policy is based on maximizing benefit. Wild cards are traditional Western allies such as Italy and Spain who feel that the current order and the EU have not benefited them, while developing nations may look at where there is more growth. What we predict is GDP per capita gaps between traditional have and have not countries starting to tighten.

As a function of this, expect further bans on sensitive industries such as semiconductors, telecommunications, cybersecurity, natural resources, energy and healthcare with aggressive moves on Huawei and SMIC. Short term winners and better monopoly positions will end up in the hands of Nokia and Ericsson. US tech firms will also find increased restrictions on the business they are allowed to do outside of the US.

Also, Chinese outbound M&A will be severely restricted against hostile nations and Chinese companies may be forced to sell out of certain ownership positions. Chinese companies may also be delisted from US exchanges, so look out for your Trip.com, Alibaba, and JD.com stocks.

As you would expect, the deeper the bifurcation, the more stress it will have on global markets. A Republican government will likely result in more severe division while Democrats will likely look towards more cooperation despite the usual sabre-rattling in order to pander to the base voter. China will likely continue to adjust and rise, as they will be able to put together a cohesive response that is proactive instead of reactive, so expect Chinese stocks to remain resilient in any outcome notwithstanding short term dips.

In all cases, expect xenophobic attacks on Asian Americans to rise.

Avatar
Matt
ex investment banking associate
https://www.linkedin.com/in/matt-walker-ssh/

Leave a Reply

Top